One week after its launch, the new 2019 Maruti Suzuki Wagon R managed to clock over 16,000 bookings. Although the latest hatchback of Maruti is a newcomer, the booking number clearly shows its popularity among the Indian auto buyers. Let’s come to a detailed comparison between Maruti Suzuki Wagon R and an already popular hatchback in India, the Tata Tiago, and see which one is the better choice for you.
>>> Also read
Tata Tiago Review 2018 India: Interior, Exterior, Performance, Specs and Prices
This article is going to provide you with a detailed comparison between the Maruti Wagon R and the Tata Tiago
Each of the two vehicles manages to have its advantage in this comparison. While the Wagon R still maintains its tallboy and sporty design from the outgoing model as one of the identifying features of the hatchback, the Tiago still looks quite fresh and muscular despite being on sale in the market for quite a long time. The two vehicles are different since one is a tallboy hatchback, the other maintains traditional hatchback design traits. Refer to the table below to have an insight into the comparison between the most outstanding exterior features of the two hatchbacks.
|
Maruti Suzuki Wagon R |
Tata Tiago |
|---|---|
|
Front: Dual-split square headlamps, redesigned grille with chrome ornaments Side profile: Blacked-out B-pillars, black finish on the C pillar Rear: Vertical taillights |
Front: Projector headlamps, chrome-surrounded fog lamps Side profile: 15-inch alloy rims Rear: Strong body panels, redesigned shut lines |
The cabin of the two vehicles have both similarities and differences. To be more specific,
|
Maruti Suzuki Wagon R |
Tata Tiago |
|---|---|
|
|
The cabin of the two cars have both similar and different interior features
Both of the Maruti Suzuki Wagon R and the Tata Tiago gets some similar safety features like a standard driver airbag and passenger airbag on the higher variants, ABS with EBD, front seatbelt alert, rear parking sensor and central locking. The main thing that sets the two vehicles apart from each other is the fact that the Wagon R base variant offers more safety features as standard, different from the Tiago which offers more on the top-spec one.
The 2019 Wagon R is 3,655 mm long; 1,620 mm wide; 1,676 mm high with a 2,435 mm wheelbase. The Tiago is 3,746 mm long; 1,647 mm wide; and 1,535 mm high with a 2400 mm wheelbase. So, the Tiago is wider and longer, but the Wagon R is higher and has a 35mm longer wheelbase. The Wagon R has a boot capacity of the Wagon R of 341 litres while that of its rival is 242 litres.
Underpinned by the new Heartect chassis, the Wagon R has a lower weight of 805 kg, which is 275 kg lighter than the Tiago. The former has a 32-litre fuel tank capacity while the latter comes with a 35-litre one. The Wagon R rides on 13-14 inch alloy wheels; Tiago features 14-15 inch ones but misses out the alloy units.
|
Dimensions |
Tata Harrier |
Mahindra XUV500 |
Differences |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Length |
3,665 mm |
3,764 mm |
- 99 mm |
|
Width |
1,620 mm |
1,647 mm |
- 27 mm |
|
Height |
1,675 mm |
1,535 mm |
+ 140 mm |
|
Wheelbase |
2,435 mm |
2,400 mm |
+ 35 mm |
|
Boot space |
341 litres |
242 litres |
+ 99 litres |
|
Tyre Size |
13 - 14 inches |
14 - 15 inches |
1 inch |
|
Fuel Tank |
32 litres |
35 litres |
- 3 litres |
|
Model |
Engine types |
Max Power |
Peak torque |
Transmission |
Mileage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maruti Suzuki Wagon R |
1.0L 3-cylinder petrol |
68 PS |
90 Nm |
5-speed AMT/MT |
22.5 kmpl |
|
1.2L 4-cylinder |
82 PS |
113 Nm |
5-speed AMT/MT |
21.6 kmpl |
|
|
Tata Tiago |
1.2L petrol |
85 PS |
114 Nm |
5-speed MT/ AMT |
23.84 kmpl |
|
1.05L diesel |
70 PS |
140 Nm |
5-speed MT |
27.28 kmpl |
The Maruti Suzuki Wagon R is powered by two petrol motors options. While the 1.0L 3-cylinder motor can produce 68 PS against 90 Nm, the 1.2L 4-cylinder unit is good for 82 PS against 113 Nm. Both of the two engines are coupled to a 5-speed AMT/MT gearbox. The mileage figures of the two engines are 22.5 kmpl and 21.6 kmpl, respectively.
The motor options of the Tata Tiago include a petrol engine and a diesel motor. The 1.2L petrol motor is good for 85 PS against 114 Nm. The 1.05L diesel unit is one of the most powerful motors which powers a hatchback in India with power/torque figures being 70 PS against 140 Nm. While the transmission options on the petrol motor include 5-speed MT and AMT unit, the transmission duties on the diesel engine are undertaken by only a 5-speed MT gearbox The two motors have fuel efficiency figures of 23.84 kmpl and 27.28 kmpl, respectively, both of them are higher than those of the Maruti Suzuki Wagon R.
The Tata Tiago is the winner in the performance comparison because of its more various motor options
In terms of handling and ride quality, the Tiago outdoes the Wagon R. The latter performs badly around corners with a lot of numb and body roll. To make matters worse, it ranks the lowest in terms of safety around the corner, due to the over-assisted steering. On the other hand, the Tiago, with a quick-responsive chassis and steering makes the handling at the corner a simple task. The Wagon R also operates much worse at high speed on the highway in terms of stability and under emergency braking circumstances.
| Model | Price |
|---|---|
| Maruti Suzuki Wagon R | INR 4.19 lakh - INR 5.69 lakh |
| Tata Tiago |
INR 3.39 lakh - INR 5.64 lakh (petrol) INR 4.20 lakh - INR 6.38 lakh (diesel) |
The price of the Wagon R starts at INR 4.19 lakh for the entry variant and can reach INR 5.69 lakh for the top-spec one. The Tata Tiago petrol is priced in the range of INR 3.39 lakh for the base variant to INR 5.64 lakh for the top variant. On the other hand, the diesel variant is priced from INR 4.20 lakh to INR 6.38 lakh. It is apparent that the Tata Tiago.
Coming to the price, the Tata Tiago continues to be the winner with a more reasonable price
|
Maruti Suzuki Wagon R |
Tata Tiago |
|---|---|
|
Amber cabin, thanks to the increased dimensions as compared to the outgoing model More versatile with larger boot space and 60:40 seats More safety features offered on the base variant Both motors come with AMT gearbox |
Being well-designed Excellent suspension offering good riding and handling quality Top-notch interior with no sign of cost sacrifice Being available in both petrol and diesel motor options with the diesel unit being one of the most powerful in the segment |
|
Maruti Suzuki Wagon R |
Tata Tiago |
|---|---|
|
Bad performance when cornering and on highways Braking system having room for improvement |
Rear seat row lack lower-thigh support Tata’s after-sales services are not as good as that of Maruti |
Generally, in this comparison, it is totally up to your personal choice as to which car is more suitable for yourself. If we have still to choose, we would recommend the Tiago over the Wagon R because of its various motor options, better mileage, price as well as riding and handling quality.
Have you decided on the vehicle for you? Share with us in the comment section below.
Read more car compare articles from IndiaAuto.com